A field of black umbrellas open and tightly packed together, creating a dark, uniform pattern, with a single bright yellow umbrella popped open on the right side, standing out as a bold focal point.

No two disputes are alike, even when they look similar on paper.

Every dispute brings its own questions, and a mediator who starts with curiosity can build a session around the people and the issues in the room.

When a Dispute Has Layers

If you practice law in Colorado, you probably have a short list of mediators you rely on for construction, business, and insurance disputes. A good list has room for mediators with different strengths, and I’m at my best in disputes like these:

  • A construction defect claim with a coverage question underneath it

  • A business dispute where the history between the parties matters as much as the numbers

  • A coverage dispute between carriers who both want to avoid a ruling that could set unfavorable precedent 

  • A dispute between an outdoor recreation company and a vendor who need to resolve this one so they can keep working together on the next project

Cases like these are where a session built around the specific dispute makes the biggest difference.

They call for a mediator who knows the terrain and still asks questions. Experience gives every mediator a sense of how certain disputes tend to unfold, and that’s a real asset. But in layered cases, the details that matter most often come out only when someone asks about them. The best sessions pair experience with curiosity about what makes this case different.

25 Years on the Other Side of the Table

Before I became a mediator, I spent more than 25 years litigating construction, insurance coverage, and business disputes. I represented business owners, insurers, contractors, homeowners, and outdoor recreation companies.

That background shapes how I mediate. I know how much preparation attorneys put into a mediation, because I did it for decades. I also know the difference it makes when the mediator comes in just as prepared. When a mediator asks what’s actually contested and what resolution would look like for each side, everyone can see the session is being built around their dispute. Once parties sense that, the conversation opens up. People talk more about what’s driving their positions, and they consider options they might have set aside.


Jennifer Arnett of Rocky Mountain ADR reviews a reference book at a marble table beside a laptop and a white construction hard hat.

Preparation starts with reading everything the parties submit.

What a Case-Specific Approach Looks Like

I build every mediation from the ground up. Before the session, I read everything the parties submit. I hold individual pre-mediation calls with each side’s counsel to understand what potential resolution looks like to each party, what barriers have prevented resolution so far, and what dynamics might be at play beneath the legal positions.

In the session itself, I build the structure around what the case needs. Sometimes that means extensive joint sessions where parties hear directly from each other. Sometimes it means spending the entire mediation in caucus. The format serves the dispute, not the other way around.

Curiosity does real work in a mediation. I ask questions that get at what the briefs can’t, follow those threads where they lead, and dig into what’s actually contested instead of assuming I know the answer because of the case type. Thorough preparation lets a session move efficiently without losing the details that matter, and that combination is what produces real movement toward resolution.


The Right Mediator for the Right Dispute

Colorado is fortunate to have many skilled mediators, a number of whom are colleagues and friends. Choosing among them comes down to the right fit for your particular dispute.

If you have a dispute like the ones above, where a coverage question, the parties’ history, or an ongoing relationship is shaping what resolution can look like, I’d welcome a call. I’d be honored to earn a place on your short list.

Se habla español.


Considering arbitration or mediation for an upcoming dispute? Contact Rocky Mountain ADR to discuss which process may be appropriate for your situation.

Jennifer Arnett, Esq.
Rocky Mountain ADR
Denver, CO
720-726-5852
jennifer@RockyMtnADR.com
www.RockyMtnADR.com

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every dispute is unique, and outcomes depend on specific facts and circumstances.

Jennifer Arnett, Esq., is the founder of Rocky Mountain ADR and brings 25 years of legal experience to her mediation and arbitration practice. She is an AAA Panel Member (Construction and Commercial Panels) and focuses on construction, insurance, commercial, and outdoor recreation disputes throughout Colorado.

Next
Next

When Can an Arbitration Award Be Overturned? What the Supreme Court's Lindell Decision Means